When researching Electric SUVs, the avalanche of numbers and technical specifications can be overwhelming. For many, it’s more helpful to hear from the people who actually live with these cars daily. On this episode of Electrify Reviewed, we’re comparing the Ford Mustang Mach-E and the Tesla Model Y, focusing on real-world experiences shared by their owners, Marlene and Kurt.
ADVERTISEMENT
Introducing the Ford Mustang Mach-E
Marlene’s journey into the world of EVs began with extensive research. She explains, “Ford has 120 years behind them with cars. The styling of the Mach-E was everything I was looking for.” Transitioning from a full-size SUV like the Dodge Durango, Marlene found the Mach-E to be a perfect blend of familiarity and innovation. The bronze edition she drives features bronze wheels, a distinctive grille, and special badging, giving it a unique aesthetic.
The Mach-E is Marlene’s first electric car, and she appreciates the technological advancements that have been made. “Being a techie person, the Mach-E melds two worlds that I enjoy,” she says. The vehicle’s build quality, safety features, and solid feel were major selling points for her.
Recently, Ford introduced a zero-interest financing deal for the Mustang Mach-E, which could entice Tesla owners to consider a switch. With the Mach-E’s starting price at $39,995, combined with the car’s impressive features, makes the Mach-E an attractive option for new buyers and those considering a trade-in.
Moreover, Ford Mach-E and Lightning owners receive free adapters for NACS chargers, expanding their charging options significantly. This move ensures that Mach-E drivers can easily access the extensive network of Tesla Superchargers, making long-distance travel even more convenient for those in the electric SUV market.
ADVERTISEMENT
Exploring the Tesla Model Y
Kurt, a former hybrid and gas car owner, switched to the Tesla Model Y about six months ago. His decision was influenced by Tesla’s improving quality, production stability, and the expanding charging infrastructure. “The car itself is very well designed, so there isn’t the range anxiety you might expect,” he says. Kurt values the ongoing improvements Tesla offers through over-the-air software updates, which have enhanced both functionality and efficiency.
The Tesla Model Y’s interior design stands out with its minimalist yet functional approach. “There’s a big long console in the middle with two phone chargers that actually work well,” Kurt notes. The car’s intuitive setup means that, once configured, driving it becomes a seamless experience.
Tesla’s recent financing offer of 1.99% APR for the Model Y adds another layer of appeal for potential buyers. This attractive rate makes the decision to switch to a Tesla even more enticing, especially considering that the 2024 Tesla Model Y starts at $44,990 before tax credits and gas savings, reflecting its premium build and advanced features.
Additionally, the Tesla Model Y was the best-selling vehicle in the world in 2023, a testament to its global appeal and the increasing adoption of electric vehicles. This milestone highlights the Model Y’s popularity and the trust that consumers place in Tesla’s innovative technology and design.
ADVERTISEMENT
Comprehensive Comparison: Ford Mustang Mach-E vs. Tesla Model Y
| Feature | 2024 Ford Mustang Mach-E | 2024 Tesla Model Y |
| Starting Price | $39,995 (before incentives and gas savings) | $44,990 (before incentives and gas savings) |
| Range | 300 miles (ext. range battery and eAWD) | 320 miles (Long Range RWD) |
| 0-60 mph | 4.1 seconds (ext. range battery and eAWD) | 6.5 seconds (Long Range RWD) |
| Seating Capacity | 5 | 5 |
| Drive Type | RWD (available eAWD) | RWD, AWD (dual motor) |
| Battery Capacity | 72 kWh (standard), 91 kWh (extended) | 75 kWh |
| Warranty | 3 years/36,000 miles (bumper to bumper), 8 years/100,000 miles (battery) | 4 years/50,000 miles (bumper to bumper), 8 years/100,000 miles (battery) |
| Unique Feature | BlueCruise semi-autonomous driving | Regenerative braking with one-pedal driving |
| Charging Flexibility | Free adapters for NACS chargers | Extensive Tesla Supercharger network |
| Technological Features | SYNC® 4A, 15.5″ touchscreen, wireless charging pad | Over-the-air updates, Sentry Mode, Tesla Mobile App |
Charging and Convenience
Both owners highlight the convenience of home charging. Marlene uses a charger at home and occasionally at work, making her transition to an EV lifestyle effortless. “I can just plug it in at home at night and drive it for the whole week or two,” she explains, noting the cost-effectiveness compared to her previous gas-powered vehicle.
Kurt has a similar setup with a Tesla charger on a 50-amp circuit at home, but he also appreciates the availability of Tesla Superchargers during road trips. He mentions a particularly convenient free charger at a hotel in Utah, stressing the benefits of Tesla’s widespread charging network.
Driving Experience and Features
Both the Mach-E and the Model Y offer unique driving experiences enhanced by their respective technologies. Marlene loves the Mach-E’s BlueCruise feature, which offers semi-autonomous driving capabilities. “It does the lane centering, the distance, and even moves over a bit if a semi is next to you,” she describes.
Kurt appreciates Tesla’s regenerative braking, which allows for one-pedal driving and adds an element of energy recovery. He also enjoys the playful features Tesla includes, like a virtual disco ball or a fireplace display, which add a fun touch to the car’s high-tech vibe.
Living with an EV: Cost and Maintenance
The cost savings of owning an electric SUV compared to a gas vehicle are significant. Marlene estimates that charging her Mach-E costs around $25 a month, compared to the $80 she used to spend on gas. Additionally, EVs require far less maintenance. “You’re never going to wear out your brakes,” she says, highlighting the minimal upkeep required beyond routine tasks like changing windshield wipers.
Kurt concurs, noting that most updates and maintenance for the Tesla Model Y are handled through software updates. “It’s like getting a new car all the time,” he says, enjoying the continuous enhancements Tesla provides.
Advice for Potential EV Owners
For those considering the switch to an electric SUV, Marlene advises understanding your lifestyle and driving needs. “Do your homework and figure out which car fits your needs and lifestyle,” she recommends. Kurt adds that the initial anxiety about charging and range quickly dissipates once you start driving an EV and experience its intuitive nature.
Final Thoughts
Both the Ford Mustang Mach-E and the Tesla Model Y have their unique strengths and appeal to different drivers. The Mach-E offers Ford’s solid build and legacy, while the Model Y impresses with Tesla’s advanced technology and continuous improvements. Marlene and Kurt’s personal experiences provide valuable insights for anyone considering the switch to electric driving.
If you’re still unsure which electric SUV is right for you, take a test drive and see for yourself.
Ford Mustang Mach-E and Tesla Model Y Photo Gallery
ADVERTISEMENT
ORIGINAL CONTENT FROM ELECTRIFY NEWS
FTC: We use income-earning auto affiliate links. Learn more.
